• Market Cap: $2,418,160,157,835.35
  • 24h Vol: $108,433,118,919.67
  • BTC Dominance: 56.67%
XBT.Market
Advertisement
  • Home
  • Coins MarketCap
  • Crypto Exchanges
  • Crypto Calculator
  • Top Gainers and Loser
  • News
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
XBT.Market
No Result
View All Result
Home Bitcoin

Is “The Howey Test” outdated? Modernizing regulations for the digital age

Jon Hartney by Jon Hartney
January 20, 2023
in Bitcoin, Blockchain, Business, Market
0
Is “The Howey Test” outdated? Modernizing regulations for the digital age
189
SHARES
1.5k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The rate and reach of cryptocurrency adoption in recent years signals the dire need for modern regulation that simultaneously safeguards investors and enables innovation to flourish.

Related articles

IOSCO’s quantum warning names Ethereum and Solana, but not the network with the most exposed keys: bitcoin

IOSCO’s quantum warning names Ethereum and Solana, but not the network with the most exposed keys: bitcoin

November 20, 2026
BingX Adds Anthropic Spot and Perpetual Futures Trading Following Nasdaq Debut

BingX Adds Anthropic Spot and Perpetual Futures Trading Following Nasdaq Debut

November 19, 2026

The rate and reach of cryptocurrency adoption in recent years signals the dire need for modern regulations that simultaneously safeguards investors and enables innovation to flourish. As it stands, most crypto tokens fall within a regulatory gray area as they don’t fit within the confines of the traditional financial system — so why should they fall prey to inapplicable, outdated rules?

Presently, the SEC applies “The Howey Test,” a legal analysis based on a 1946 U.S. Supreme Court ruling, to differentiate between securities and non-securities. The SEC asserts that securities are an “investment of money in a common enterprise with a reasonable expectation of profits to be derived from the efforts of others.”

However, there is a glaring void of regulatory clarity on who determines this classification and how it applies to today’s constructs. The majority of digital assets resemble commodities and some were specifically designed to avoid securities laws.

Furthermore, in contrast to the citrus grove investors involved in SEC v. Howey, who had no intention of buying or eating the fruit they were backing, crypto enthusiasts are often looking well beyond the return on investment (ROI). Today’s crypto buyers see a future in which consumers use tokens to transact on the blockchain and for entry into decentralized apps, among other use cases.

I’d like to propose an alternative process to characterize crypto coins and tokens below.

Fully decentralized vs. fully centralized

There is a sliding scale when it comes to digital assets, ranging from fully decentralized to fully centralized. Where assets fall on this spectrum plays a huge role in whether both industry leaders and government officials see them as either a security or non-security. If a holder of a particular crypto token does not have the expectation of profit based on the efforts of a centralized team, then that crypto should not be considered a security.

For example, the SEC’s former Director of Corporate Finance, William Hinman, stated in a 2018 speech that based on his understanding of the Ethereum network’s decentralized structure, Ethereum offerings and its associated sales would not be considered securities transactions. The debate about whether Ethereum can be labeled a security has reemerged following the network’s switch to a proof-of-stake (PoS) model, which greatly changed how the blockchain functions. However, I’d argue that shifting to PoS should not affect the assumption that Ethereum (ETH) is effectively and directly decentralized, given the extensive holding of Ethereum.

Most blockchain startups initiate their projects with a native coin or create a native coin derived from their original ERC-20 offering. Native coins fall under the category of centralized currency because they have their own designation, and acquiring significant decentralization is hard to achieve.

Since the Howey Test is not a “3 out of 4 is not bad” test, if any of the four aspects are not met, then the asset in question is not a security. Given Hinman’s statement, any asset that can show that it is decentralized is clearly not a security.

You can read more about decentralization determination here.

Join the community where you can transform the future. Cointelegraph Innovation Circle brings blockchain technology leaders together to connect, collaborate and publish. Apply today

Additional categories

While an asset may not meet the requirements to be deemed a decentralized currency, it is not automatically deemed a security. The asset may contrarily fall into a number of other buckets such as centralized currency, contract or organization.

As more and more individuals lose faith in the U.S. Federal Reserve, some are placing trust in centralized stablecoins, like USDT or USDC, that keep reserves of cash off-chain to ensure that their coins are always valued at $1. Those holding these stablecoins are simply looking to protect the value of their money and not expecting significant profits. But because stablecoins like USDT and USDC are backed by securities, the SEC believes that they should be regulated.

Decentralized autonomous organizations (DAOs) are governed by smart contract algorithms without a centralized authority. Oftentimes, DAOs issue tokens so that users can participate in the decision-making of the organization. While many believe that these decentralized collectives don’t qualify as securities, lawmakers have issued stark warnings that crypto companies can’t hide behind DAOs to avoid regulation.

The solution: Transparent regulatory framework

The landmark case against Ripple underscores how different agencies within the U.S. government aren’t even in agreement on this issue, as FinCEN declared it was not a securitywhile the SEC argued that it was. All various modes of tokens and crypto coins should be analyzed by the SEC according to which unique category they’d fall under, as this dilemma isn’t black or white. 

In the interim, there is a lot at stake for the future of crypto either way this case falls. If Ripple can prove that the SEC has taken an unclear, arbitrary approach to regulating crypto, then an important precedent is set that places the power back in the blockchain. If the SEC reigns supreme, then the governmental agency has legal say in the procession and development of regimenting decentralized finance.

Ultimately, digital assets are notoriously difficult to place into buckets, and until we have new guidelines for the crypto securities market, there will continue to be disagreement and confusion, which could, in tandem, stifle the industry.

The information provided here is not legal advice and does not purport to be a substitute for advice of counsel on any specific matter. For legal advice, you should consult with an attorney concerning your specific situation.

Arie Trouw is the co-founder of XYO and founder of XY Labs.


This article was published through Cointelegraph Innovation Circle, a vetted organization of senior executives and experts in the blockchain technology industry who are building the future through the power of connections, collaboration and thought leadership. Opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect those of Cointelegraph.

Learn more about Cointelegraph Innovation Circle and see if you qualify to join

Read Entire Article
Tags: CointelegraphCryptocurrencyInvestmentMining Bitcoin
Share76Tweet47

Related Posts

IOSCO’s quantum warning names Ethereum and Solana, but not the network with the most exposed keys: bitcoin

IOSCO’s quantum warning names Ethereum and Solana, but not the network with the most exposed keys: bitcoin

by Jon Hartney
November 20, 2026
0

IOSCO's 63-page quantum-risk report names Ethereum, Solana and Tron as examples and never mentions bitcoin, where an estimated 693 million...

BingX Adds Anthropic Spot and Perpetual Futures Trading Following Nasdaq Debut

BingX Adds Anthropic Spot and Perpetual Futures Trading Following Nasdaq Debut

by Jon Hartney
November 19, 2026
0

PANAMA CITY, November 19, 2026 – BingX, the world’s leading multi-asset trading platform, today announced that Anthropic (Nasdaq: ANT) is...

Pulsar Enables USDT Deposits on TRON, Expanding Access to Everyday Stablecoin Payments

Pulsar Enables USDT Deposits on TRON, Expanding Access to Everyday Stablecoin Payments

by Jon Hartney
November 19, 2026
0

Geneva, Switzerland, November 19, 2026 — Pulsar Money today announced support for USDT deposits on the TRON network, allowing users...

OmenX announces $2 million in funding from Informed Ventures and launches on-demand 30-second Bitcoin predictions

OmenX announces $2 million in funding from Informed Ventures and launches on-demand 30-second Bitcoin predictions

by Jon Hartney
November 19, 2026
0

The Base-native leveraged prediction market platform expands its offering across crypto, global financial assets, sports and esports Toronto, November 19,...

MEXC’s Hacken-Audited November 2026 Proof of Reserves Shows Reserve Ratios Above 100% Across Major Assets

MEXC’s Hacken-Audited November 2026 Proof of Reserves Shows Reserve Ratios Above 100% Across Major Assets

by Jon Hartney
November 19, 2026
0

Mutsamudu, Comoros, November 19, 2026 – MEXC, a pioneer in 0-fee digital asset trading, has released its November 2026 Proof...

Load More
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Crypto, Fintech push back against banks’ war on open banking

Crypto, Fintech push back against banks’ war on open banking

October 21, 2025
Bitcoin Cash (BCH) Pulls Back After Yesterday’s Big Push While Ecoterra Goes Up and Up

Bitcoin Cash (BCH) Pulls Back After Yesterday’s Big Push While Ecoterra Goes Up and Up

July 1, 2023
Bitcoin ETFs shed $1.2B in red week, but Schwab remains bullish

Bitcoin ETFs shed $1.2B in red week, but Schwab remains bullish

October 18, 2025
SUI Price Hits All-Time High – But Questions About Valuation Remain

SUI Price Hits All-Time High – But Questions About Valuation Remain

October 17, 2024
All aboard! Elon Musk’s Vegas Loop now taking Dogecoin payments

All aboard! Elon Musk’s Vegas Loop now taking Dogecoin payments

0
Crypto owners banned from working on US Government crypto policies

Crypto owners banned from working on US Government crypto policies

0
Korean startup Uprise lost $20M shorting LUNC

Korean startup Uprise lost $20M shorting LUNC

0
Ethereum testnet Merge mostly successful — ‘Hiccups will not delay the Merge.’

Ethereum testnet Merge mostly successful — ‘Hiccups will not delay the Merge.’

0
IOSCO’s quantum warning names Ethereum and Solana, but not the network with the most exposed keys: bitcoin

IOSCO’s quantum warning names Ethereum and Solana, but not the network with the most exposed keys: bitcoin

November 20, 2026
BingX Adds Anthropic Spot and Perpetual Futures Trading Following Nasdaq Debut

BingX Adds Anthropic Spot and Perpetual Futures Trading Following Nasdaq Debut

November 19, 2026
Pulsar Enables USDT Deposits on TRON, Expanding Access to Everyday Stablecoin Payments

Pulsar Enables USDT Deposits on TRON, Expanding Access to Everyday Stablecoin Payments

November 19, 2026
OmenX announces $2 million in funding from Informed Ventures and launches on-demand 30-second Bitcoin predictions

OmenX announces $2 million in funding from Informed Ventures and launches on-demand 30-second Bitcoin predictions

November 19, 2026

XBT.Market

This website is an automated news feed powered by the Nebulome cloud system. The site is made possible by YYC TECH Consulting and Alberta Digital Mining Company. As a team with major crypto and bitcoin enthusiasm, we have curated major sources of news, trading and financial data to bring you, our viewer, an unbiased source of truth.

Recent Posts

  • IOSCO’s quantum warning names Ethereum and Solana, but not the network with the most exposed keys: bitcoin November 20, 2026
  • BingX Adds Anthropic Spot and Perpetual Futures Trading Following Nasdaq Debut November 19, 2026
  • Pulsar Enables USDT Deposits on TRON, Expanding Access to Everyday Stablecoin Payments November 19, 2026
  • OmenX announces $2 million in funding from Informed Ventures and launches on-demand 30-second Bitcoin predictions November 19, 2026
  • MEXC’s Hacken-Audited November 2026 Proof of Reserves Shows Reserve Ratios Above 100% Across Major Assets November 19, 2026

News Categories

  • Bitcoin
  • Blockchain
  • Business
  • Market
  • Uncategorized

Tags

bitcoinMagzine Cointelegraph Cryptocurrency insidebitcoins Investment Mining Bitcoin NewsBTC

Quicklinks

  • Home
  • Coins MarketCap
  • Crypto Exchanges
  • Crypto Calculator
  • Top Gainers and Loser
  • News
  • Contact Us

© 2022 Xbt.Market - Powered by YYC Tech Consulting & ADMCO.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Coins MarketCap
  • Crypto Exchanges
  • Crypto Calculator
  • Top Gainers and Loser
  • News
  • Contact Us

© 2022 Xbt.Market by Nebulome.

  • Steakhouse EURCV Morpho VaultSteakhouse EURCV Morpho Vault(STEAKEURCV)$0.000000-100.00%
  • FibSwap DEXFibSwap DEX(FIBO)$0.0084659.90%
  • TruFin Staked APTTruFin Staked APT(TRUAPT)$8.020.00%
  • bitcoinBitcoin(BTC)$84,372.003.58%
  • ethereumEthereum(ETH)$1,885.365.68%
  • tetherTether(USDT)$1.000.00%
  • rippleXRP(XRP)$2.186.84%
  • USDEXUSDEX(USDEX)$1.07-0.53%
  • binancecoinBNB(BNB)$617.995.03%
  • Wrapped SOLWrapped SOL(SOL)$143.66-2.32%
  • solanaSolana(SOL)$128.974.23%
  • usd-coinUSDC(USDC)$1.000.01%
  • dogecoinDogecoin(DOGE)$0.1736117.78%
  • cardanoCardano(ADA)$0.687.61%
  • tronTRON(TRX)$0.2342340.79%
  • staked-etherLido Staked Ether(STETH)$1,884.065.48%
  • Gaj FinanceGaj Finance(GAJ)$0.0059271.46%
  • Content BitcoinContent Bitcoin(CTB)$24.482.55%
  • USD OneUSD One(USD1)$1.000.11%
  • wrapped-bitcoinWrapped Bitcoin(WBTC)$84,309.003.84%
  • ToncoinToncoin(TON)$4.157.66%
  • UGOLD Inc.UGOLD Inc.(UGOLD)$3,042.460.08%
  • ParkcoinParkcoin(KPK)$1.101.76%
  • chainlinkChainlink(LINK)$14.027.76%
  • leo-tokenLEO Token(LEO)$9.211.17%
  • stellarStellar(XLM)$0.2743585.70%
  • avalanche-2Avalanche(AVAX)$19.647.71%
  • Wrapped stETHWrapped stETH(WSTETH)$2,256.395.40%
  • USDSUSDS(USDS)$1.00-0.01%
  • SuiSui(SUI)$2.429.03%
  • shiba-inuShiba Inu(SHIB)$0.0000137.71%
  • hedera-hashgraphHedera(HBAR)$0.17284810.00%
  • Yay StakeStone EtherYay StakeStone Ether(YAYSTONE)$2,671.07-2.84%
  • polkadotPolkadot(DOT)$4.257.34%
  • litecoinLitecoin(LTC)$85.265.04%
  • bitcoin-cashBitcoin Cash(BCH)$314.248.23%
  • mantra-daoMANTRA(OM)$6.301.94%
  • Pundi AIFXPundi AIFX(PUNDIAI)$16.000.00%
  • PengPeng(PENG)$0.60-13.59%
  • Bitget TokenBitget Token(BGB)$4.664.95%
  • wethWETH(WETH)$1,884.285.66%
  • Ethena USDeEthena USDe(USDE)$1.00-0.04%
  • Binance Bridged USDT (BNB Smart Chain)Binance Bridged USDT (BNB Smart Chain)(BSC-USD)$1.00-0.18%
  • MurasakiMurasaki(MURA)$4.23-13.71%
  • Black PhoenixBlack Phoenix(BPX)$3.351,000.00%
  • Pi NetworkPi Network(PI)$0.714.53%
  • HyperliquidHyperliquid(HYPE)$13.729.80%
  • Wrapped eETHWrapped eETH(WEETH)$2,003.675.53%
  • WhiteBIT CoinWhiteBIT Coin(WBT)$28.350.76%
  • moneroMonero(XMR)$217.841.31%
  • Zypto TokenZypto Token(ZYPTO)$0.037139-3.47%
  • uniswapUniswap(UNI)$6.217.66%
  • AptosAptos(APT)$5.395.79%
  • PepePepe(PEPE)$0.00000811.37%
  • daiDai(DAI)$1.00-0.01%
  • nearNEAR Protocol(NEAR)$2.635.26%
  • XT.comXT.com(XT)$3.08-1.65%
  • Layer One XLayer One X(L1X)$23.35454.66%
  • sUSDSsUSDS(SUSDS)$1.050.05%
  • okbOKB(OKB)$48.762.12%
  • gatechain-tokenGate(GT)$22.883.58%
  • crypto-com-chainCronos(CRO)$0.1015853.46%
  • Coinbase Wrapped BTCCoinbase Wrapped BTC(CBBTC)$84,342.003.68%
  • MantleMantle(MNT)$0.814.44%
  • Tokenize XchangeTokenize Xchange(TKX)$33.460.86%
  • internet-computerInternet Computer(ICP)$5.517.85%
  • ethereum-classicEthereum Classic(ETC)$17.074.81%
  • OndoOndo(ONDO)$0.817.47%
  • First Digital USDFirst Digital USD(FDUSD)$1.00-0.12%
  • aaveAave(AAVE)$168.6110.19%
  • Aerarium FiAerarium Fi(AERA)$7.14-13.11%
  • Ethena Staked USDeEthena Staked USDe(SUSDE)$1.170.30%
  • BSCEXBSCEX(BSCX)$237.310.49%
  • Official TrumpOfficial Trump(TRUMP)$10.354.36%
  • vechainVeChain(VET)$0.0233636.04%
  • cosmosCosmos Hub(ATOM)$4.538.09%
  • fantomFantom(FTM)$0.70-1.56%
  • BittensorBittensor(TAO)$231.277.72%
  • BlackRock USD Institutional Digital Liquidity FundBlackRock USD Institutional Digital Liquidity Fund(BUIDL)$1.000.00%
  • EthenaEthena(ENA)$0.3616194.37%
  • render-tokenRender(RENDER)$3.6710.91%
  • filecoinFilecoin(FIL)$2.927.72%
  • CelestiaCelestia(TIA)$3.181.75%
  • Black AgnusBlack Agnus(FTW)$0.000183423.46%
  • Lombard Staked BTCLombard Staked BTC(LBTC)$84,465.004.02%
  • POL (ex-MATIC)POL (ex-MATIC)(POL)$0.2063993.13%
  • KaspaKaspa(KAS)$0.0682239.38%
  • STAUSTAU(STAU)$0.17397910.95%
  • FasttokenFasttoken(FTN)$4.020.01%
  • Sonic (prev. FTM)Sonic (prev. FTM)(S)$0.5212.98%
  • algorandAlgorand(ALGO)$0.1896979.65%
  • ORA CoinORA Coin(ORA)$4.885.92%
  • ArbitrumArbitrum(ARB)$0.3397526.22%
  • Arbitrum Bridged USDT (Arbitrum)Arbitrum Bridged USDT (Arbitrum)(USDT)$1.000.07%
  • GGTKNGGTKN(GGTKN)$0.1121180.75%
  • kucoin-sharesKuCoin(KCS)$11.231.19%
  • Solv Protocol SolvBTCSolv Protocol SolvBTC(SOLVBTC)$84,076.003.32%
  • fetch-aiArtificial Superintelligence Alliance(FET)$0.4856098.68%
  • optimismOptimism(OP)$0.776.43%
  • StoryStory(IP)$4.75-2.68%